The question is quite simple. You get to choose one superhero to be your protector, while the other 9 try to kill you. Who do you choose as your protector? Some ground rules: assume that your protector is willing to do anything to protect you, even if it is against their established nature (i.e. Batman or Superman would be willing to kill to ensure your safety) assume that the other 9 heroes are willing to do anything to kill you, even if it is against their established nature (i.e. willing to cause collateral damage, torture for information, etc.) let's ignore any time travelling shenanigans because that just breaks the system (looking at you Flash & Superman) the other characters are permitted to team up or work in unison in an attempt to kill you (it would be interesting to see if your choice of protector would vary if the others had to work independently of one another) it's NOT a popularity contest, choose the hero that you feel gives you the greatest chance at survival, not necessarily your favorite of the group I had this discussion with a friend of mine and we each independently reached the exact same conclusion. I'll wait a couple of days before posting my analysis and submitting my vote because I'm interested in everyone's uninfluenced/unbiased opinion. Choose wisely!